top of page

Why being a smart AI detective matters: critical thinking for young AI explorers

  • Writer: Frobo
    Frobo
  • May 20, 2025
  • 3 min read

Updated: Sep 10, 2025


Hello AI Explorers!

Welcome back to our AI adventure! Today, we're talking about something SUPER important: how to be a smart AI detective using your amazing critical thinking skills!


Have you ever played "spot the difference" between two similar pictures? Or figured out that a magic trick isn't really magic? That's your critical thinking brain in action! And when it comes to AI, these detective skills are your superpower!



An AI-generated frog detective.
An AI-generated frog detective.

What is critical thinking?


Critical thinking is like having a special magnifying glass for your brain that helps you:

  • Ask good questions

  • Look for evidence

  • Spot when something doesn't make sense

  • Make smart decisions based on facts


When you use critical thinking with AI, you become an "AI Detective" who can tell the difference between what's real, what's helpful, and what might not be quite right.


Why your detective skills matter in the world of AI


🕵️‍♀️ AI can make mistakes

Even the smartest AI can get things wrong sometimes! Just like humans, AI isn't perfect.


Example: If you ask an AI, "Who is the tallest person in the world?" it might give you an answer based on old information. Your detective brain might think: "Hmm, I should check if this is still true today!"


🤔 AI doesn't always know everything

AI learns from information people give it, but it doesn't know everything!


Detective challenge: Ask an AI when your school was built or who won yesterday's local soccer game. It probably won't know unless that specific information was part of its training data!


👁️ AI can't always tell what's real

AI might not be able to tell if a picture has been changed or if a story is made up.


Try this: Show an AI a picture of you riding a dinosaur (that you created with a photo app). The AI might think it's real because it can't tell the dinosaur was added digitally!


Become an AI detective: your critical thinking toolkit


Tool #1: The "How do you know?" question

When AI tells you something interesting:

  • Ask: "How do you know this is true?"

  • Look for other reliable sources

  • Compare different answers


Example: If AI tells you "Cats sleep 20 hours a day," check a pet website or ask a veterinarian to confirm!


Tool #2: The "That doesn't sound right" feeling


Trust your instincts when something seems off!


Example: If AI says "The moon is made of cheese," your brain probably thinks "Wait a minute, that can't be right!" That's your critical thinking at work!


Tool #3: The Source detective


Information comes from somewhere! Good detectives always check their sources.


Detective game: When you learn something new from AI, try to find three other places that confirm the same information.


AI detective stories: Kids using critical thinking


Mia's weather project

10-year-old Mia was doing a science project about weather prediction. She asked an AI for help forecasting the weather in her town.


Critical Thinking Win: Mia noticed the AI didn't ask for her location! She realised it couldn't make accurate predictions without knowing where she lived. Instead of just accepting what the AI said, she used a real weather service for her project.


Jake's history report

Jake was writing a report about his town's history. He asked an AI for information about when his town was founded.


Detective move: Jake noticed the AI gave three different founding dates when he asked multiple times! This made him suspicious, so he visited his local library instead and found the correct information.


Why your brain is still the boss


Even the smartest AI tools are made to HELP your brain, not replace it! Here's why your thinking skills will always be special:

  • You can notice when something doesn't make sense in a way AI can't

  • You have real-life experiences AI doesn't have

  • You can feel when something isn't right

  • You can make creative connections AI might miss


Be a responsible AI explorer


When using AI, remember:

  1. Question what you're told

  2. Check facts from multiple sources

  3. Don't share personal information

  4. Use AI as a helper, not the final answer

  5. Trust your own thinking skills


Critical thinking challenge!


Try this activity with friends or family:

  1. Ask an AI a tricky question about something you know well (your pet, your town, your favorite sport)

  2. See if the answer is correct or if there are mistakes

  3. Use your detective skills to spot any errors

  4. Write down how you knew the AI was right or wrong


Remember: The best technology users are the ones who know when to use their own amazing brains!


Ribbit, ribbit,

//Frobo



 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page